Nada Khan is an Exeter-based NIHR Academic Clinical Fellow in general practice and GPST4/registrar, and an Associate Editor at the BJGP. She is on Twitter: @nadafkhan
‘I’m not sure I know any doctors who don’t have a Plan B now. Everyone’s thinking, I can’t do this for ever. And they can’t. The NHS is 110,000 members of staff short at the moment – we can all work out where the problem is. It’s something no amount of soundbites are going to sort. It needs money spent and it needs money spent in the right places. We need to recruit and we need to retain – because there’s no point running the bath if the plug isn’t in. When I left in 2010, I was the outlier as someone who left the NHS. There had only been one other person in my cohort of 300. But, with no end in sight, you would have to be deranged not to think ‘I can’t maintain this level of work for ever.’
Adam Kay, speaking to The Big Issue in February 20221
…12,250 GPs could be ‘lost to the profession within five years’…
The above is a long quote from Adam Kay, but to maintain the full sentiment of his remarks, it would not do him justice to cut it short. Adam Kay left a senior training post in Obstetrics and Gynaecology and the last chapter of his book ‘This is Going to Hurt’ details the reasons why. I thought of Adam Kay when the results of the latest GP Worklife Survey were published; the survey warns of a mass exodus from the profession with a third of the respondents stating their intention to quit direct patient care within five years.2 If these results were extrapolated to the headcount of 37,123 GPs, 12,250 GPs could be ‘lost to the profession within five years’.3 And of those GPs under the age of 50, 16% are thinking of leaving their role within five years.
Several GP leaders have picked over the wreckage of the findings and suggest any number of reasons why GPs do not want to work face-to-face, citing ‘burnout’, exhaustion from the Covid pandemic and long working hours. The especially worrying aspect of the Worklife Survey is that so many GPs are thinking of leaving so early in their careers. But is there any evidence to tell us why GPs leave their jobs?
Why do GPs leave?
Turnover in the medical profession has been a growing concern over the past 15 years, and several studies have tried to unpick the reasons why. In 2016, Natasha Doran and colleagues found that the overarching reason why early-stage GPs left their jobs was the ‘changing role of general practice and its impact’. Once job satisfaction was negatively impacted, ‘the combined pressures of increased patient demand and the negative media portrayal left many feeling unsupported and vulnerable to burnout and ill health, and, ultimately, to the decision to leave general practice.’4 Another study of GPs in central England found that GPs planned to leave practice due to the volume of workload, time spent on ‘unimportant tasks’ and lack of job satisfaction. GPs also cited the impact of work-related pressures, growing workload, and the consequent stress’.5
More in-depth qualitative research builds on these themes of pressure, workload and job satisfaction. An interview study of GPs in the South West of England from 2016 considered the factors influencing GPs reasons for wanting to leave direct patient care.6 Again, there was no one headline reason why GPs wanted to leave; the reasons were complex and based on ‘a range of job-related and individual factors’. GPs reported frustrations around the unrealistic expectations of what GPs could or should deliver, coupled with frustration around being undervalued.
The results from these studies resonate with each other. To bring together research in this area, a systematic review of qualitative research published in 2020 aimed to synthesise and unpick the reasons why GPs leave direct care. Most of the included studies were UK-based, and the authors describe how the dynamics around low job satisfaction and other combined pressures such as workload and stress leave GPs feeling ‘unsupported and vulnerable to burn-out and ill health, and ultimately the decision to leave general practice’.7
These studies suggest that GPs seem to be able to cope until the point where their job satisfaction dips, then the multiple pressures of practice create an untenable load.
These studies suggest that GPs seem to be able to cope until the point where their job satisfaction dips, then the multiple pressures of practice create an untenable load. This sounds like a classic ‘Swiss cheese model‘ of medial error to me; or perhaps a tipping point at which GPs say ‘enough is enough’. And in terms of the association between intention and action, previous research has shown the probability of leaving a job increases when GPs state an intent to leave, and of those who leave their jobs, the majority do not return.8
The above studies, however, were conducted before the COVID-19 pandemic and a lot has changed in the past two years, probably not for the best, in terms of how GPs view their careers. We need up to date, in-depth understanding about the ‘Why is this happening?’, in order to think about the ‘How do we even begin to fix this?’ And lest the problem falls into the political trap of endless measurement of the problem – some planning and research into solutions would also be welcome.
The future of the workforce crisis – a plea
The government’s promises on increasing GP numbers have not yet come to fruition, so what can we really expect from the policymakers in terms of real, ‘un-spun,’ action to increase GP numbers? Ominously, the workforce crisis amongst doctors is not new or limited to primary care. Reflecting back on Adam Kay’s quote, is the end of this workforce crisis ever going to be in sight, and if not, how long can we continue to work in an increasingly deranged system? Research has identified many, fixable, problems – this needs to be a focus for ongoing research, innovation and policy.
- Lobb A. Adam Kay: ‘Before the pandemic the NHS was running on empty and it turned out those were the good old days’: The Big Issue; 2022 [Available from: https://www.bigissue.com/life/health/adam-kay-before-the-pandemic-the-nhs-was-running-on-empty-and-it-turned-out-those-were-the-good-old-days/.
- Odebiyi BW, B.; Gibson, J.; Sutton, M.; Spooner, S.; Checkland, K. Eleventh National GP Worklife Survey 2021. Policy Research Unit in Commissioning and the Healthcare System.
- Bostock N. 12,000 GPs plan to quit within five years, major survey suggests: GP Online; 2022 [Available from: https://www.gponline.com/12000-gps-plan-quit-within-five-years-major-survey-suggests/article/1752892.
- Doran N, Fox F, Rodham K, Taylor G, Harris M. Lost to the NHS: a mixed methods study of why GPs leave practice early in England. Br J Gen Pract. 2016;66(643):e128-35.
- Dale J, Potter R, Owen K, Parsons N, Realpe A, Leach J. Retaining the general practitioner workforce in England: what matters to GPs? A cross-sectional study. BMC Fam Pract. 2015;16:140.
- Sansom A, Terry R, Fletcher E, Salisbury C, Long L, Richards SH, et al. Why do GPs leave direct patient care and what might help to retain them? A qualitative study of GPs in South West England. BMJ Open. 2018;8(1):e019849.
- Long L, Moore D, Robinson S, Sansom A, Aylward A, Fletcher E, et al. Understanding why primary care doctors leave direct patient care: a systematic review of qualitative research. BMJ Open. 2020;10(5):e029846.
- Hann M, Reeves D, Sibbald B. Relationships between job satisfaction, intentions to leave family practice and actually leaving among family physicians in England. Eur J Public Health. 2011;21(4):499-503.