Clicky

Book Review: The State of Medicine by Margaret McCartney

13 January 2017

thestateofmedicine300The State of Medicine is an eloquent, passionate, comprehensive, and, in many ways, dispiriting overview of the repeated damage inflicted on the NHS at the whim of successive governments. The frustration of the author, a GP from Glasgow, pours from every page, every paragraph and every sentence, as she contrasts the efforts of doctors to practice evidence based, safe, humane and cost-effective medicine, in a system that is routinely upended and overhauled according to manifesto sound bite, political opinion and, occasionally, outright self-interest.

Whilst the general themes of this book will surprise few who work in the NHS, the actual facts and figures, such as the vast sums wasted on management consultancy firms, may make the eyes of even the most hardened cynic water.

Each chapter begins with an interview with someone who is able to give a different perspective on our collective woes. Amongst these are some real gems that offer unexpected insights into different niches of the NHS world. The words of an A&E consultant who was working at Mid Staffs during the scandal may send a there-but-for-the-grace-of God shiver down your spine, and the thoughts of a Nobel prize winning economist will have you bewildered that there are still so many advocates of insurance based health care systems.

Dr McCartney offers a clear account of the follies of the last few decades and a personal view of where and how the NHS should proceed from here with ideas such as buffering the NHS from policy makers, funding it properly, treating health professionals with respect, and actually basing policy on evidence.

The message of this book is important. We must hope that it reaches a general readership, or, hoping even more bravely, that it reaches an audience amongst the political classes.

Adam Staten

Adam Staten trained at Cambridge University and Kings’s College London School of Medicine. After serving a short service commission in the Royal Army Medical Corps he returned to the NHS and is now a GP partner in Milton Keynes. He likes to bang on about general practice, burnout, and the future of medicine and the NHS.

Visit his website (www.adamstaten.com) for more details on his books.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
rhinoplastyinhyderabad

Nice Article to read .It is helpful for all to get idea about medicine.want to get General physician doctors guidelines from this Article. .Thank you for sharing

Latest from Opinion

Why face-to-face still saves lives

Remote consulting is excellent for repeat prescriptions, routine results, straightforward infections in the young and well, and selected mental health follow-ups. But general practice is not primarily populated by the young and well..

“It’s OK to ask sensitive questions but….”

"We asked people with lived experience of forced migration, homelessness and sex-work their ideas on how best to approach sensitive conversations to ensure patients feel safe, comfortable, respected, listened to and cared for." Learning from a QI project.

Doctor, heal thyself

In general practice, we often prescribe the advice we fail to follow: to rest, to take time away from work, to protect boundaries. Small acts of humanity can blunt the edges of an unforgiving system. But lasting change will depend on the

Fragmented care: a hidden cost of diabetes management

If general practice is to remain the cornerstone of chronic disease management, we need to be part of efforts to reconnect care - not by taking on more work, but by having a clearer voice in how systems are designed around patients.
1
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x